Worst bike parking award: Jewish Community Center of San Francisco

The racks get crowded even at 4pm, way before the pickup rush.

The racks get crowded even at 4pm, way before the pickup rush.

Bike parking throughout San Francisco is getting pretty crowded, especially compared to last year, and I can’t imagine how bad it’s going to get when the weather gets better. Sometimes I have to park the bike as far as a block away, which is trivial by comparison to how far we used to have to park our car, back in the driving days. But it annoys me even so because bike parking is easy and cheap to install (and also because I have become hopelessly lazy about walking).

There is plenty of space to install more of the terrible racks they have (kind of a worst-best alternative) but they haven't even done this.

There is plenty of space to install more of the terrible racks they have (kind of a worst-best alternative) but they haven’t even done this.

But there is bad bike parking and there is terrible bike parking, and the worst bike parking by far on my daily rounds is at my son’s after school program at the Jewish Community Center of San Francisco. It is the worst because it is a half-hearted attempt to put in bike parking that was horrifically slipshod, and it is the worst because despite multiple complaints from me and others in person, and in writing, plus a dedicated meeting I had with a building manager about it, they have done absolutely nothing to fix it. In Matt’s most recent discussion with the building staff yesterday afternoon, they said they weren’t planning to do anything about it either, because “we need that space for drop offs and pickups by car.”

These tree cages aren't even attached to anything, but there aren't any better alternatives.

These tree cages aren’t even attached to anything, but there aren’t any better alternatives.

The bike racks are pretty standard U-loops along the sidewalk. However they were installed smack up against bollards placed on the sidewalk, so it is only possible to use one side of the rack, because the bollards keep a bike from getting close enough to the other side. There are only a few racks, so given how many people arrive by bike, there are never enough spaces and people end up parking bikes to the cages protecting the trees. And there’s still not enough space. Even worse, the racks are so close-packed against other obstacles built into the street that it is virtually impossible to park a cargo bike there unless you get the one rack that isn’t smack against a bollard that allows for a bike wider than a fixie. The JCCSF at 5pm has bikes piled up outside with child seats, cargo bikes, and trailer-bikes, all ridden by parents like me who have chosen to ride with their kids instead of drive. Yet parking a bike outside the JCC is so difficult that trying to pick up my son on the Bullitt sends me into a fury every evening that I try it. I would retreat to a meter but there are no meters in the huge drop-off/pickup/bus zone outside the building.

By contrast, the after school program gives every family two cards to put in the car(s), whether you drive or not, that allow you to park a car for free for 15 minutes in their underground garage to pick up kids. They have a carefully orchestrated car pickup zone at the end of the day, complete with walkie-talkies, to make sure that parents who drive barely have to slow down to pick up their kids. Yet this pickup is so notorious for road rage that I get emails from the director of the after school program asking driving parents to please chill out and act like adults.

The JCCSF pays lip service to active transportation, like everyone else, but their bike racks tell the real story. I pick up my son there by bike because I go everywhere by bike, although I’m astonished that anyone else does. Yet they do. And given that there is such unmet demand, imagine how much less space they’d “need for drop offs and pickups by car” if they had some decent bike racks.

[Thank you, internet! We'd been asking JCCSF to install new bike racks for months, and were being blown off as recently as the day before I wrote this post. After posting, I got an email that very evening saying that they'll be installing 6 new custom bike racks that will hold 12 bikes. In addition, they're going to try letting parents have keycode access to a locked courtyard with an additional bike rack for preschool and after school drop-offs and pickups. We are thrilled! I know that some readers wrote to to JCCSF on our behalf and it is very much appreciated.]

5 Comments

Filed under advocacy, family biking, San Francisco

5 responses to “Worst bike parking award: Jewish Community Center of San Francisco

  1. What’s with all those bollards anyway? So many and why at that location? If they just removed the bollards and replaced them with bike racks there would be plenty of room and cars would be (somewhat) prevented from driving on the sidewalk. Unless they’re worried about car bombers or something.
    And the pandering to parents who pick up and drop off in cars vs bikes is particularly galling.

  2. Susanne

    Hi. This is the letter I wrote to JCCSF after I read your post. I don’t even live in CA but heard your pain and wanted to help. We cyclist need to stick together. Happily, I got a response which I will post next.

    Good afternoon,

    It has come to my attention that bicyclists dropping off and picking up their children from Jewish Community Center of San Francisco After School Program are experiencing parking space problems. Cycling has become a popular and economical/environmental form of transportation. As a result many establishments may need to upgrade their bike parking facilities by adding more bike parking racks. It is an act of goodwill that is greatly appreciated and much needed by cycling parents. I respectfully urge you to consider the inconvenience/stress the current bike parking situation presents. Transportation cycling is a fast-growing, nation-wide trend that benefits everyone. Children experience life and travel outdoors at bike speed. No fossil fuel is used so less pollution. It reduces the number of cars on the road. The more parents that ride their children to JCCSF on bikes the less car congestion and wait time for car-driving parents at pick-up time which makes everyone happy.

    Bikes Racks. They’re a good thing.

    Thank you,

    Susanne

  3. Susanne

    Here is the nice response I received. It sounds like your bike racks are already on order. Good job, parent cyclists!

    Dear Susanne,

    My name is Chris Sundblad, Director of Building Operations for the JCCSF. The suggestion you made regarding the capacity for bikes was forwarded to me. I am writing to let you know, that we will be installing 6 new bike racks on California Street by mid-March (they are made to order). This will increase the bike capacity an additional 12 (2 bikes per rack). I want to thank you for sharing your concern and suggestion with us, and I invite you to make contact with me at any time.

    Regards,

    Chris

    Chris Sundblad
    Director of Building Operations & Security
    Jewish Community Center of San Francisco
    3200 California Street, San Francisco, CA 94118
    Phone: 415.292.1212 Fax: 415.276.1563

  4. I think this is just great. I this is for the welfare of all especially pedestrians then for me, this parking system for bikes works. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s